March 26th, 2008
Webquest critique
Posted by hayds in Uncategorized
The following is the opinions of a small group of university students on a webquest activity. We are all viewing the contents as beginning Mathematics Teachers.
Here is a link to the Chess activity.
Strengths
- Task has good Knowledge Integration with history (cold war)
- Uses research as a teaching strategy
- Relevant links are included for students to read more about different aspects of the task
- Plenty of technology incorporated with links to films and opportunities for students to create part of web pages
- Students have the chance to play chess with one another
Weaknesses
- Irrelevant to maths syllabus
- Research is only of interest to chess fans and requires a degree of background knowledge of chess
- Task 4 is more suited for D&T where design and ease of use is important
- Seems to be a trivial activity aiming at chess promotion
- Outcome is not mathematical and does not require higher-order thinking (more a structured writing task)
- No meaningful motivation for students
- Purely individual work – lost opportunity for collaboration
For anyone interested in learning chess from a grandmaster, here is a blog on the games of Karjakin Sergey.